Skip to content
Patrick Hartoonian

Organic growth since 2012

Portrait of Patrick Hartoonian

Organic growth advisor

Organic growth, built to last.

I grew Credible from 1 million to 6 million monthly visitors. I've led in-house SEO teams, audited sites of every size, and worked through acquisitions. Now I work with a few companies at a time.

Where I've done the work

Brands I've helped grow, in-house and as an advisor.

  • NerdWalletOrganic growth2025 – now
  • CredibleDirector, organic2017 – 2022
  • InsurifyDirector, SEO2023 – 2024
  • Compare.comSEO, via Insurify2023 – 2024
  • SundaeSenior director, SEO2022 – 2023
  • CoverRightAdvisory client
  • Artificial Turf SupplyAdvisory client
  • Sanabria Injury LawAdvisory client
  • Moonlight Vacation RentalsAdvisory client
  • Miami CyberAdvisory client
  • and the restFull record →

No. 1 · How I think

Be the answer AI recommends.

Search clicks still matter. But more buyers now ask AI what to buy, and the goal is to be the product it names. I get you there in three steps.

  1. Anchor

    Put your own data on the pages that matter. Tighten your topics and site structure. Show first-hand experience on every page.

  2. Amplify

    Earn links and mentions from the sites AI reads, so they say the right things about you.

  3. Align

    Make the web agree on who you are, and correct the AI answers that get you wrong.

Point of view

Fewer, better pages.

Most sites don't have a content shortage. They have a quality spread. Google judges sites as well as pages, so a long tail of thin, outdated or duplicate URLs holds back the pages that should be winning. I've argued this for six years, and Google's leaked ranking documentation now backs it up.

So before writing anything new, I map the topics an expert needs to cover in your category, keep what earns its place, and consolidate or remove the rest. New content then goes into a site Google already trusts.

No. 2 · Experience

In-house first, advisor always.

Work history: years, company and role, and one result
YearsCompany and roleResult
2025 – NowNerdWallet · currentOrganic Growth, Consumer CreditBuilding and scaling organic growth systems across credit cards, wealth, lending and insurance.
2020 – NowHartoonian Advisory · currentOrganic Growth AdvisorAdvisory and implementation for companies in insurance, Medicare, legal, home services, travel, B2B SaaS and cybersecurity. 6× growth in qualified new users and 9× growth in incremental revenue across clients, 2025 vs. 2024.
2023 – 2024InsurifyDirector, SEO6× growth in monthly revenue from SEO (2024 vs 2022). Led a team of 6 SEOs, PMs and data analysts.
2022 – 2023SundaeSenior Director, SEOStood up the SEO program, built alignment across the company, and put the organic growth playbook in place.
2017 – 2022CredibleManager, SEO → Director, Organic MarketingScaled from 1M to 6M monthly visitors and 10× annual revenue with a team of 12 editors and SEOs.
2013 – 2015Juicy ResultsSEO Specialist → Manager, Organic MarketingManaged 25+ agency clients. 3× growth in monthly new users, year over year.
2012 – 2013YextBusiness DevelopmentLocal SEO strategies for client lead generation.

Since 2017 I've led in-house SEO teams. I've worked side by side with product, design, engineering, paid and editorial, helped with acquisitions, and presented growth plans to leadership and boards.

No. 3 · What I do

Four ways to work together.

See services in detail →

Technical SEO audit

Fixed fee

A full crawl, index and site-quality review that shows what is capping your growth and the order to fix it. You get a prioritized plan your team or agency can act on, walked through on a call. Most engagements start here.

More on Technical SEO audit →

Organic growth retainer

Monthly

Senior strategy and hands-on execution: roadmap, page and content systems, technical fixes, internal linking, and local search where it matters. Measured against leads and revenue, not just traffic.

More on Organic growth retainer →

AI search strategy

Scoped per engagement

Get recommended in AI answers, not just ranked in Google. I add first-hand data to your key pages, earn mentions from the sources AI systems read, and make the web consistent about your brand, including correcting wrong AI answers.

More on AI search strategy →

Research and diligence

Project-based

Audience research, opportunity sizing, competitor analysis, and acquisition diligence for teams buying or merging sites.

More on Research and diligence →

No. 4 · Who it's for

Who I help.

  1. Funded startups

    You need a senior SEO lead, without making a full-time hire yet.

  2. In-house teams

    You have people doing the work and want senior eyes on the plan.

  3. Companies buying or merging sites

    You need to know what you're buying, and how to combine sites without losing traffic.

  4. Local businesses

    You want more calls and visits from Google Maps. I manage your Google Business Profile, reviews and local pages.

No. 5 · Results

What moved, and by how much.

Credible

1M to 6M monthly visitors, 10× annual revenue

Credible: 1M to 6M monthly visitors, 10× annual revenueEstimated organic traffic from Ahrefs, 3-month average, indexed to Jan 2017 = 1×. 10× in Apr 2022.Jan 2017: 1×Feb 2017: 0.9×Mar 2017: 0.9×Apr 2017: 1×May 2017: 1.1×Jun 2017: 1×Jul 2017: 1×Aug 2017: 1.2×Sep 2017: 1.3×Oct 2017: 1.2×Nov 2017: 1×Dec 2017: 0.8×Jan 2018: 0.8×Feb 2018: 0.7×Mar 2018: 0.7×Apr 2018: 0.8×May 2018: 0.9×Jun 2018: 1×Jul 2018: 1.2×Aug 2018: 1.3×Sep 2018: 1.4×Oct 2018: 1.3×Nov 2018: 1.3×Dec 2018: 1.3×Jan 2019: 1.5×Feb 2019: 1.6×Mar 2019: 1.8×Apr 2019: 1.9×May 2019: 1.8×Jun 2019: 1.7×Jul 2019: 1.7×Aug 2019: 1.7×Sep 2019: 1.9×Oct 2019: 2.1×Nov 2019: 2.2×Dec 2019: 2.2×Jan 2020: 2.2×Feb 2020: 2.3×Mar 2020: 3.3×Apr 2020: 3.6×May 2020: 3.9×Jun 2020: 3.8×Jul 2020: 4.1×Aug 2020: 4.3×Sep 2020: 4.8×Oct 2020: 5×Nov 2020: 5.1×Dec 2020: 4.5×Jan 2021: 4×Feb 2021: 3.6×Mar 2021: 3.7×Apr 2021: 3.9×May 2021: 4.1×Jun 2021: 4.2×Jul 2021: 4.6×Aug 2021: 5.2×Sep 2021: 5.6×Oct 2021: 6.1×Nov 2021: 6.8×Dec 2021: 7.7×Jan 2022: 8.7×Feb 2022: 9.3×Mar 2022: 10×Apr 2022: 10×
Estimated organic traffic (Ahrefs), 3-month average, indexed to Jan 2017 = 1×
The problem
A challenger in student loan refinancing and personal loans, up against SoFi, NerdWallet and Bankrate.
What I did
Led a team of 12 editors and SEOs; took top search share in both categories.
The result
Estimated organic traffic grew about 10× from 2017 to my exit in April 2022.

Insurify

6× monthly SEO revenue, 2024 vs. 2022

Insurify: 6× monthly SEO revenue, 2024 vs. 2022Estimated organic traffic from Ahrefs, 3-month average, indexed to Jan 2023 = 1×. 1.1× at handoff in May 2024, 11× in Nov 2026.Jan 2023: 1×Feb 2023: 1.1×Mar 2023: 1.3×Apr 2023: 1.2×May 2023: 1.2×Jun 2023: 1.2×Jul 2023: 1.3×Aug 2023: 1.4×Sep 2023: 1.5×Oct 2023: 1.6×Nov 2023: 1.5×Dec 2023: 1.3×Jan 2024: 1.1×Feb 2024: 1×Mar 2024: 1.1×Apr 2024: 1.1×May 2024: 1.1×Jun 2024: 1.2×Jul 2024: 1.3×Aug 2024: 1.6×Sep 2024: 1.9×Oct 2024: 2.3×Nov 2024: 2.5×Dec 2024: 2.8×Jan 2025: 3.1×Feb 2025: 3.5×Mar 2025: 4.2×Apr 2025: 5.1×May 2025: 5.9×Jun 2025: 6.2×Jul 2025: 7.7×Aug 2025: 9.5×Sep 2025: 12×Oct 2025: 13×Nov 2025: 13×Dec 2025: 12×Jan 2026: 10×Feb 2026: 8.7×Mar 2026: 8.7×Apr 2026: 8.1×May 2026: 7.7×Jun 2026: 7.3×Jul 2026: 8.8×Aug 2026: 11×Sep 2026: 12×Oct 2026: 12×Nov 2026: 11×
Estimated organic traffic (Ahrefs), 3-month average, indexed to Jan 2023 = 1×
The problem
Past SEO strategy mistakes had capped growth.
What I did
Rebuilt the content library around quality, ran link acquisition, coordinated engineering, design, UX and CRO, and turned the homepage into a non-branded landing page.
The result
The strategy kept compounding after I handed off in May 2024. Organic traffic reached about 2.8× the 2023 level by the end of that year and about 11× today.

Compare.com

About 15× organic traffic vs. 2023

Compare.com: About 15× organic traffic vs. 2023Estimated organic traffic from Ahrefs, 3-month average, indexed to Apr 2023 = 1×. 0.7× at handoff in May 2024, 15× in Nov 2026.Apr 2023: 1×May 2023: 1×Jun 2023: 1.1×Jul 2023: 1.2×Aug 2023: 1.4×Sep 2023: 1.6×Oct 2023: 1.6×Nov 2023: 1.5×Dec 2023: 1.2×Jan 2024: 1×Feb 2024: 0.8×Mar 2024: 0.7×Apr 2024: 0.7×May 2024: 0.7×Jun 2024: 0.6×Jul 2024: 0.6×Aug 2024: 0.6×Sep 2024: 0.9×Oct 2024: 1.1×Nov 2024: 1.3×Dec 2024: 1.1×Jan 2025: 1.1×Feb 2025: 1.2×Mar 2025: 1.5×Apr 2025: 1.4×May 2025: 1.2×Jun 2025: 1×Jul 2025: 1.6×Aug 2025: 2.8×Sep 2025: 4.8×Oct 2025: 6.3×Nov 2025: 7×Dec 2025: 6.3×Jan 2026: 5×Feb 2026: 3.7×Mar 2026: 3.7×Apr 2026: 9.2×May 2026: 14×Jun 2026: 19×Jul 2026: 20×Aug 2026: 22×Sep 2026: 21×Oct 2026: 18×Nov 2026: 15×
Estimated organic traffic (Ahrefs), 3-month average, indexed to Apr 2023 = 1×
The problem
An established comparison site whose organic traffic had been sliding for two years when Insurify acquired it in 2023.
What I did
Ran the Insurify playbook: rebuilt the content library around quality, ran link acquisition, and coordinated engineering, design and CRO.
The result
The turnaround took hold after handoff. Organic traffic is now about 15× its 2023 level.

CoverRight

~150 to ~14.5K estimated monthly organic visits in two years

CoverRight: ~150 to ~14.5K estimated monthly organic visits in two yearsEstimated monthly organic traffic from Ahrefs, 3-month average: about 153 in Jan 2023 and 14.5K in Dec 2024.Jan 2023: 153Feb 2023: 149Mar 2023: 201Apr 2023: 444May 2023: 663Jun 2023: 1.1KJul 2023: 1.6KAug 2023: 2KSep 2023: 2.4KOct 2023: 3.3KNov 2023: 5KDec 2023: 5KJan 2024: 4.2KFeb 2024: 2.6KMar 2024: 3KApr 2024: 3.9KMay 2024: 4.8KJun 2024: 5.1KJul 2024: 5.6KAug 2024: 6.4KSep 2024: 7.7KOct 2024: 11.1KNov 2024: 14KDec 2024: 14.5K
Estimated monthly organic traffic (Ahrefs), 3-month average
The problem
An early-stage Medicare startup starting organic search from zero.
What I did
Applied the same growth system: a content library that covers the category, supporting links, technical debt cleared, and PR to amplify it.
The result
Built a new organic acquisition channel from almost nothing over two years.

Artificial Turf Supply

2.4× organic traffic vs. 2021

Artificial Turf Supply: 2.4× organic traffic vs. 2021Average monthly estimated organic traffic from Ahrefs by year, indexed to 2021: 2021 1×, 2022 0.7×, 2023 2.2×, 2024 1.9×, 2025 2.2×, 2026 YTD 2.4×.2021: 1×2022: 0.7×2023: 2.2×2024: 1.9×2025: 2.2×2026 YTD: 2.4×
Average monthly estimated organic traffic (Ahrefs) by year, indexed to 2021 = 1×
The problem
Search results in this category reward sites with carts, checkout and per-square-foot pricing. ATS has none of them, so it competes at a structural disadvantage.
What I did
Rebuilt location pages for the priority Texas metros, pruned the index down to the major markets, productized location content, added product carousels to priority pages, and ran Google Business Profile and local citation work.
The result
Organic traffic has held at about 2× the 2021 level or higher for four straight years.

No. 6 · Kind words

In their words.

  1. May 2024

    “Patrick is a thoughtful and knowledgeable SEO leader… Would highly recommend him for any SEO/organic growth leadership position.”

    — Ross Hudgens, CEO, Siege MediaPatrick was a client, across multiple companies
  2. June 2024

    “Patrick is that rare SEO expert who also excels at communication… I've always been impressed by his ability to communicate highly technical concepts in ways that are easily understandable for peers, leaders and board members who are not SEO experts.”

    — Evelyn Pimplaskar, Director of Content, InsurifyWorked with Patrick at two companies
  3. June 2024

    “SEO isn't always an easy concept for everyone to understand. Patrick did a wonderful job communicating his vision in ways non-SEOs could buy into.”

    — Jessica Edmondson, Director of Data Journalism & Outreach, InsurifyWorked with Patrick on the same team

From LinkedIn recommendations. See all on LinkedIn

Serious about long-term growth?

Tell me where organic growth is stuck. We'll do a 30-minute call. Bring Search Console access if you can, and you'll leave with the two or three things I'd fix first, whether or not we work together.

Let's talk →